Report on the Destruction to Palestinian
Institutions in Nablus and Other Cities (Except Ramallah)
Caused by IDF Forces
Between March 29 and April 21, 2002
(Report Updated April 22)
Palestinian NGO Emergency Initiative in
Jerusalem
“The aim of this war (1948) not merely to uproot the
Palestinians from their homeland but also to erase it from their memory”
Meron Benvenisti in his book Landscape of Memory
(translated from Arabic, 2002)
Table
Of Contents
II.
Palestinian National Authority Institutions
1. Palestinian
National Council (PNC) and PLO Department of Refugee Affairs
2. Governorate
(security and civil offices):
1. Bisan
Center for Research and Development (Nablus City branch) 5
2. East Jerusalem YMCA offices in Nablus
3. Dwikat Building at entrance to Balatta
Camp: The Committee for Palestinian Refugee Right.
Jaffa Cultural Center and
Deputy Hussam Khader Office
II.
Anabta Village (Tulkarm District)
2. The Anabta Women’s
Charitable Organization
1. General Union of
Palestinian Women, Tulkarim
On the night of April 3, 2002 at approximately 9:00 p.m., hundreds of
Israeli tanks, armored vehicles and bulldozers entered the city of Nablus from
3 directions; the west, the south and the east. The invasion led to a great
loss of human life (71 thus far including five children) and the injury of many
more. Less quickly quantifiable is large-scale damage and destruction to the
city’s infrastructure as well as to its irreplaceable cultural heritage
centered in the Old City (Casbah).
This very preliminary report can only point in a general way to the
areas and types of institutional destruction caused by the IDF invasion and
cannot clearly assess the specific circumstances in which ancient buildings in
the Old City were destroyed or heavily damaged– answers to such questions will
have to wait for more specialized assessments. The pattern of damage to public
institutions outside of the Old City suggests that primarily destruction
occurred due to their being used as strategic military locations by the IDF
(i.e.high buildings for sniper positions). At the same time, some confiscation
was undertaken at these locations.
While it is true that much of the fighting was for a period centered in
the Old City, as well as at various times Askar Camp, Ras al Aein and al
Shabaka Street (all areas which suffered the most damage), other institutions
located outside of these areas seem to have been particular targets. In
specific independent mass media stations suffered a similar fate as those in
other towns (such as Ramallah) in which systematic destruction of their offices
and equipment was undertaken by the Israeli army. In addition, the offices the
Municipality Building suffered destruction and vandalism while being far from
centers of fighting.
The following is a very
preliminary overview of the destruction to public institutions and cultural
heritage sites in the City of Nablus. It is in no way comprehensive but is
simply an attempt to make what information has been gathered thus far available
to concerned parties.
The Old City of Nablus dates back to 71 BC, and is considered one of the
oldest cities in the world. Its buildings belong to different historical
periods dating from the Roman, Byzantine, Crusade, Islamic and Ottoman periods.
Since the coming of the PNA, in 1994 Nablus Municipality, undertook with the
support of international donors a major renovation and rehabilitation project
of the Old City. Streets, arcades,
houses, public springs, mosques and churches have been renovated under the
supervision of specialized international agencies including UNESCO.
During this invasion, the Israeli army has destroyed and damaged large
parts of the Old City’s cultural heritage sites. The Old City was hit by
rockets, shelled by tanks and then huge drills and military caterpillars went
on to make further destruction from the ground. A one dunum area of the Tabaneh Kan’an area was completely
flattened by F-16 bombing.
The following is a preliminary report on the damages that occurred to
the cultural heritage of Nablus:
1. Al-Khadra Mosque,
(more than 1000 years old), was 85% destroyed. The beautifully sculpted and
inlaid mihrab was destroyed. The IDF used bulldozers with drill and other
attachments.
2. Al-Kabeer Mosque,
which is 1800 years old (Being Byzantine Church before), was 20% destroyed.
3. Al-Satoon Mosque,
which is 1600 years old (Being Byzantine Church before), was 20% destroyed
(windows also shattered).
4. Greek Orthodox
Church located in Yasmin quarter, which is 400 years old, was 40% destroyed
(Building not destroyed but the Alter place, chandelier, pews, bibles,
shattered glass, cracked walls). The structure is too unsafe to be used for
prayer. Also outside rooms belonging to the Church heavily damaged.
5. At least 60
houses of different historical periods (1500 AD –1940) were totally destroyed.
Over 200 houses were partially destroyed.
6. At least 80% of
the renovated stone-paved streets of the Old City were totally damaged.
7. Al-Shifa Turkish
bath, which is 400 years old, was hit by three rockets, which caused 50% damage
to the bath. The part destroyed was the more important historical section of
the baths – the destruction was by apache gunship shelling.
8. The eastern
entrance of the Khan (old market) which is 220 years old, was completely
destroyed.
9. Many supporting
arches and arcades above the streets were severely damaged.
10. 2 soap factories (300 and 500 years old
respectively) were completely destroyed. One of them belongs to Kanaan family.
Destroyed by F16 bombing.
11. 3 soap factories of between 300 and 500 years old were
partially destroyed.
12. 7 Roman water sources were completely
destroyed.
The Engineers Union of Nablus evaluated in 21 April 2002 the destruction
in the Old City by 80 million US$.
Information: Municipality: Tel: 972 (0)9 2388170, Fax: 972 (0)9 2379718
E mail: mcrc_n@yahoo.com;
Jawwal: 059 237237 (Majed); Cel: 052 201459 (Ayman)
Jawwal: 059 777060 (Ayman)
Alaa Badarna: photographer
free laser. Tariq al Mahaba FM. 059 207 635; 057 870035; 09 237 13 72
The premises of Palestinian National Council (PNC) and
Palestinian Refugee Department of PLO were occupied for a number of days by IDF
forces. Besides using the building as a sniper position (it is strategically
located at the entrance to the Old City in a high building) soldiers also
vandalized the offices and confiscated data files. The following is reported by two officials who work in the
building.
External damage
The external metal doors to the building were blown up and completely
destroyed
Internal damage VANDALISM:
The offices were completely vandalized. 8 windows are broken (Aluminum and
glass); 4 Computers were thrown on the floor, broken 3 tables and files from
cabinets strewn across the floor. Soldiers defecated in a number of rooms - the
offices are filthy.
Confiscation:
Hard Disks from PNC offices were taken from a number of offices including all
the files related to internal correspondence, personnel and financial
accounting.
Impact on work: Palestinian National Council and Palestinian Refugee Department of PLO
have clearly suffered considerable financial loss due to the destruction or
damage to equipment, furnishings and physical structure. How much data and
documentation has been confiscated or damaged is impossible to determine until
now.
Information: Said Salameh: Employee at Palestinian
Refugee Department of PLO and Bilal Al Shakhshir, PNC member.
Located at the Southern Entrance to the City
(A British Mandate “Taggert Building)
The governorate is housed in a British Mandate “Taggart Building” it is
large three storey structure surrounding an inner courtyard. It has been
strafed by helicopter gunship on a number of occasions prior to the recent
invasion and had already been badly damaged. The following is additional damage
to the building incurred during the current invasion. Besides security services
offices it also contains regional departments of the Interior Ministry and the
Ministry of Civil Affairs.
Structural Damage: Six tanks shelled the building for a period of
thirty minutes. The façade of the building was severely damaged. Widespread
internal damage, especially in the civilian offices. IDF forces then went onto
ransack the building.
Confiscation: Hard Disks and many paper files were taken.
Vandalism: Computers, equipment and furniture were smashed.
Information: Alaa Badarna: (local journalist) 059 207635; 057 870035; 09
2371372
(Location: Near Nablus Square)
A number of regional offices of Ministry’s are located in this building
including: PLC, Committee for Land Defense (PLO), Institute of General
Information (Office of Head of PNA), Development of Women Health Department
(Ministry of Health), Front of Popular Struggle (political party). On April 4
around 2:00 p.m., Israeli Military Forces shelled this eight-storey building
which may have been targeted potentially because it is a high building near the
entrance of the Old City. There are no fighters in side of it during this
destruction.
STRUCTURAL DAMAGE: The building from the exterior is moderately
damaged:
The windows of the first 4 floors are completely
destroyed. Those of the other 4 floors are partially damaged. All internal
doors, which were locked, were broken into and badly damaged.
Vandalism:
Many files strewn on the floor and damaged furniture.
Information: Ali Salameh (PLC):
059 20 44 10.
Location:
The
City hall was hit by the bullets during first three days of invasion, many gl
are broken. The area is not a fighting area.
VANDALISM:
the Statue of Zafer Al Masri, the former mayer of Nablus, was completely
destroyed. The parking place was totally damaged. Concerning the municipal
Vehicles, 25 vehicles were partially damaged, one ladder car was totally
damaged.
Information: Municipality Tel: 972 (0)9 2388170, Fax: 972 (0)9 2379718
E mail: mcrc_n@yahoo.com
Jawwal: 059 237237 (Majed) Cel: 052 201459 (Ayman), Jawwal: 059 777060
(Ayman)
Alaa Badarna: photographer
free laser. Tariq al Mahaba FM. 059 207 635; 057 870035; 09 237 13 72
In
8/4/2002, the IDF raided Nablus branch of Bisan Center for Research and
Development. All the offices in the building were invaded.. This area is not
fighting area.
The
Beisan Center’s two doors were broken (one of them by explosives). Video
machine destroyed, hard disks taken from computers and computer monitor
smashed. Books and papers strewn on floor. Broke small office items. Not
possible to assess what paper files missing. One camera was stolen.
Kitchen
equipment was also smashed.
Note:
Soldiers placed sponges on all faucets and toilets, no explanation for this
strange action..
Adress:
Allol and Abu Salha Bulding, Hitin Street
Information:
from Izzat Abdul-Hadi, Director (Ramallah)
On
05 April 2002 a contingent of IDF soldiers blew up the entrance of the eight
story building where the YMCA offices are located in Nablus. The YMCA offices
in Nablus include program Rehabilitation, Women's Training, Extension Services,
Youth Opportunities and Youth and Community Development Programs.
They
entered the offices by force and destroyed the main door, all of the interior
doors and windows of the offices. The furniture, office equipment and documents
were thrown all over the floors. The soldiers entered all the other offices in
the building and destroyed the main doors, the interior doors and windows. All
the contents of the offices were searched, many of the offices' furniture,
computers and other office equipment were destroyed. “Hally Internet Company”,
was subjected to total destruction of all its furniture and equipment.
The
building contains 50 to 60 doctors' clinics, offices of lawyers, business and
non-governmental institutions..
Information:
The East Jerusalem YMCA. 29 Nablus Road, P. O. Box 19023, East Jerusalem Tel.
No.: +972(0)2 628 6888(Operator),
+972(0)2 628 9307(Direct)
Fax
No.: +972(0)2 627 6301, Email: jmajaj@east-jerusalem-ymca.org
STRUCTURAL
DAMAGE: During three days from April 4th to 7th, these
offices were shelled. All the glasses were destroyed. Many bullets hit the
offices inside. Explosion made 2 computers damaged.
Address:
Al Suk Street, Entrence of Balata Camp
Information:
Deputy Hussam Khader. Jawwal: 059205 410
On Wednesday 4 April at 1:00, the IDF surrounded and blasted the
building from tanks until 3:00. 3 rooms of this station were damaged: one of
them is completely destroyed. About 35% of offices destroyed. This station was
targeted as there is no fighting in this area.
Alaa Badarna, the photographer, and a sound engineer stayed in the
building for 7 days without food and only with water. The International Red
Cross was not able to evacutate them. Finally the Associated Press evacuated
them.
Now The station can hardly work after this destruction. The team
transmit the sound of Al Jazira TV.
Adress Al Adel Street. Abdel Hadi Bulding, 7th Floor.
Information: Amer Abdel Hadi amer@tmfm.net tel: 09 237 13
72 and Alaa Badarna: photographer free laser. Tariq al Mahaba FM. 059 207 635;
057 870035; 09 2371372.
During the invasion of Nablus from 4 until 9 April, the Israeli army
caused damage to 7 major schools in the city. The main objective was to enter
the old city but also to use the space for maneuvering the tanks. These schools
are:
1- Al-Fatimeya Girls
Schools (in the entrance of the Old City), which is over 400 years old. About
30% of the school is damaged (wall, rooms). Parts of the walls surrounding the
school is also damaged; the entrance of the school is destroyed, in addition to
some rooms.
2- Rashda Girls School,
Parts of the walls surrounding the school were damaged, as well as the gates of
the school.
3- Jamal Abdelnasser Girls
School (in the entrance of the Old City). Parts of the walls surrounding the
school were damaged as well as the gates of the school and some rooms.
4- Hawwash School (in the
entrance of the Old City).
5- Abdelraheem Mahmoud
School.
6- AL-Ansari School.
7- Zafer Al-Masri School
(in the entrance of the Old City).
Damage: In general the damage inflicted on these schools comprises:
parts of the walls surrounding the school were damaged, the entrance of the
school destroyed in addition to some rooms. All these schools are now closed which
prevent hundreds of pupils from continuing their studies in a normal way.
Information: Municipality Tel: 972 (0)9 2388170, Fax: 972 (0)9 2384027,
E mail: mcrc_n@yahoo.com
Jawwal: 059 237237 (Majed), 059 777060 (Ayman), Cel: 052 201459 (Ayman),
It has been
extremely difficult to access information from most other towns since they have
remained under curfew without break since they were invaded. Also, many
re-occupied towns (Jenin, Tulkarim, Nablus etc..) have had no electricity or
phone lines for the past week). Below is information on damages to governmental
and non-governmental organizations in areas besides Ramallah. All of the
following information is very preliminary given that it is based on information
from people who have reached sites while the curfew is still on and thus only a
very quick picture could be drawn.
Location: Manger
Square
This report was
made by an employee in the emergency services room set up in the municipality
building. He and another 15 emergency workers were in the building when it was
invaded by IDF troops. They were detained for a number of hours within the
building and then taken to a detention center where he and others were
subsequently released. The information he was able to provide was based on his
eyewitness account when the events were underway and is very preliminary. The
IDF continues to occupy the Municipality building as of April 13th.
Destruction: There has
been destruction of many external and internal doors, as well as many windows
smashed. A number of interior walls of the building have been destroyed.
Destroyed/
vandalized furniture. Approximately twenty mobile stretchers were taken from
the premises; seven of them were returned severely damaged. Also destroyed were
three video cameras and a cassette inside one of them was confiscated.
[Employees could
make only an initial assessment of damage, due to the ongoing curfew.]
Number of staff: 60
External
destruction
The entrance door
was completely destroyed.
Internal
destruction
VANDALISM: Just
before the incursion, the municipality had transferred some archeological
artifacts from Tulkarm fearing that they might be destroyed; half of the
relocated collection was destroyed. The fire-alarm system, the central
telephone system and individual telephones were destroyed. Municipal files were
torn and thrown on the ground. The entire library, book shelves and books, were
thrown on the floor. Some desks were damaged.
SANCTIONED THEFT:
Two municipal computers were taken. In the library, a computer and a camera
were taken.
CONFISCATION: All
of the municipality's floppy disks were removed.
STRUCTURAL DAMAGE:
The windows and doors were broken.
(Information
supplied by Mayor,Hamdallah Hamdallah; who has photos and a detailed report on
the destruction.)
This charitable
organization has a staff of 11 and offers health services and social and
cultural activities for women, provides relief for the poor and outreach for
the elderly, in addition to operating a preschool (230 children) and daycare
(10 infants).
External damage
The outside wall
was blown up with explosives, which also damaged the building. The gate had
several bullet or shrapnel holes in it.
Internal
destruction
VANDALISM: There
was a great deal of superficial damage. All of the glass was found broken.
(Information provided
by Itaf Al-Qabbaji )
The Tulkarim branch
of the GUPW is engaged in promoting and marketing embroidery and other
traditional handicrafts produced by village women in the area.
External destruction
The door was blown
open with explosives.
Internal
destruction
VANDALISM: All
drawers were apparently searched and all files were opened. The office
equipment appeared to be intact. Embroidery had been strewn all over the floor
and stepped on.
STRUCTURAL DAMAGE :
Windows were broken.
(Information
supplied by Fawziyyeh Yahya Aboud)
This is a preschool
with 6 employees serving 70 children.
External
destruction Main door destroyed.
Internal
destruction
VANDALISM: All of
the children's the toys were thrown on the ground and many smashed. The
wall-to-wall carpeting has been ripped and in some places removed, the small
puppet theater was destroyed.
(Information
supplied by Fawziyyeh Yahya Aboud)
For
further information on this report contact:
Sari
Hanafi, Director of Palestinian Refugee and Diaspora Centre, Shaml : Hanafi@p-ol.com;
050 335 103; 059 47 3798